Path dependency is a big reason coaches keep running drills, practice structures and methods that don't carry over to games.
Walk into most gyms and you will see the same things: jogging laps, static stretching, 1-on-0 layup lines and the three-man weave. The practice looks neat and organized.
But if you stop and ask the coach why they are running these specific drills, the most common underlying answer is simple: "Because that is how my coach did it."
Coaching research calls this the custodial approach. Coaches design their sessions around their own history as players, and those habits get passed on even when there are better ideas about how players learn.
Copying is part of it too. Coaches take a system from a well-known mentor without asking if it fits the players in front of them.
Why tradition is hard to give up
Why is path dependency so hard to break? Because tradition is comfortable. When a coach implements a rigid, 5-on-0 offensive sequence, the players eventually memorize the pattern, and it looks beautiful in an empty gym.
Drills without a defense also keep the coach busy. You can instruct, correct technique and manage every movement. The players look good in practice, but the scoreboard often tells a different story.
Pressure from parents and the problem with "muscle memory"
There is outside pressure too. Parents and administrators have a picture of what a "good" practice looks like. A loud practice full of mistakes can look like bad coaching to them.
That picture comes from information processing theory, which treats the brain like a computer that stores "muscle memory." So the game gets broken into parts, like a crossover against a cone. The player learns the move but never the defender who decides when to use it.
Episode 87 of The Transforming Basketball Podcast: The whole episode is about muscle memory. The hosts compare the "information processing" view, which treats the brain like a central executive issuing orders, with ecological dynamics. They specifically highlight the "storage problem," questioning how it would be physically possible for the body to store a separate, idealized movement pattern for every situation a player might face in a game.
Why it breaks down on game day
Coaching the way we were coached separates what players see from what they do. In a game nothing is planned ahead. The player moves in response to what the defense shows them.
A player shouldn't pass because the pattern says pass. They pass because they see an opening, which we call an affordance: an opportunity for action.
What happens with on-air practice
When players spend hours on moves against air, they practice the action without the information that tells them when to use it.
- They can look great in an empty gym.
- Then a live defender shows up and they hesitate.
- The rehearsed move doesn't fit what the defense is doing.
If your practice has no defenders and no live decisions, players never get to practice reading them.
Technical demonstration showing the difference between a cone drill and a 1-on-1 small-sided game with a live defender.
Free resource
21 SSGs for your next practice.
A free PDF of small-sided games you can run right away. A practical first taste of the approach.
4 ways to break the cycle
Breaking path dependency takes some nerve. Here is where we start, using ecological dynamics and the constraints-led approach (CLA).
1. Redefine skill
Skill is not a fixed technique the player repeats. It is the player's ability to organize their body to solve the problem the game gives them right now.
2. Ditch the cones and add a live defender
Keep practice representative of the game. The simplest step is to remove the cones and make sure there is a live defender and a real decision in almost every activity.
3. Design games instead of running drills
Don't stop practice every thirty seconds to explain. Use the CLA to change the task constraints and let the players find solutions.
- Example: If you want to stop contested mid-range jumpers, change the scoring system so rim finishes are worth 3 points and mid-range shots are worth minus-1. Players will start passing up the mid-range shot on their own.
4. Expect practice to look messy
Learning is messy. When you introduce live small-sided games, players will turn the ball over and look uncoordinated at first. Resist the urge to go back to "safe," unopposed drills.
Conclusion
The game has changed and our practices can change with it. Keep the parts of your own playing history that still help your players, and question the rest.
If you are ready to start making that shift, our constraints-led approach guide lays out the framework, and how to avoid reverting to traditional coaching habits helps you stay the course when old habits pull you back.
Keep developing your coaching.
Connect these ideas with the Success Pathway, activity video library, coaching community and monthly live sessions.
Explore the membership
